A Fuzzy Based Mathematical Model for Vendor Selection and Procurement Planning with Multiple Discounts in the Presence of Supply Uncertainty

Document Type: Research Paper

Authors

Department of Industrial Engineering, University College of Engineering, University of Tehran, P.O. Box 11155-4563, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Supplier selection and material procurement planning are the most important issues in supply chain management. This decision is complicated when the buyers face with discount price schemes. In real situation, each supplier may apply different methods such as different types of discount schedules and various types of payment in order to increase market share. In this situation, buyers try to select the best supplier/s by considering all tangible and intangible factors which may be included in this decision problem. Mohammad Ebrahim and Razmi (2009) introduced a Meta heuristic model in order to select the best suppliers and determine the procurement plan under two types of discount offers. In this paper, a fuzzy bi-objective model is proposed for single item single period supplier selection and purchasing problem under capacity constraint, supply uncertainty and budget limitation. This model includes different kinds of discount (all-unit discount, incremental discount). In addition, different methods for payments which ordinary may be proposed by each supplier are considered in this model. Finally, an interactive fuzzy programming approach (TH method), -constraint method and reservation level driven Tchebycheff procedure (RLTP) are applied to solve this bi-objective model. The efficiency of each method is evaluated by using an additive utility function which is offered by decision maker.

Keywords

Main Subjects


[1] Alves MJ., Climaco J. (2004), A note on a decision support system for multi objective integer and
mixed-integer programming problems; European Journal of Operational Research 155; 258–265.
[2] Amid A., Ghodsypour SH., O’Brien C. (2006), Fuzzy multi objective linear model for supplier
selection in a supply chain; International Journal of Production Economics 104; 394–407.
[3] Amid A., Ghodsypour S.H., O’Brien C. (2009), A weighted additive fuzzy multi objective model for
the supplier selection problem under price breaks in a supply Chain; International Journal of
Production Economics 121(2); 323-332.
[4] Benton WC. (1991), Quantity discount decisions under conditions of multiple items, multiple suppliers
and resource limitations; International Journal of Production Research 29; 1953–1961.
[5] Burke GJ., Carrillo JE., Vakharia AJ. (2008), Heuristics for sourcing from multiple suppliers with
alternative quantity discounts; European Journal of Operational Research 186; 317-329.
[6] Burke GJ., Carrillo JE., Vakharia AJ. (2004), Sourcing decisions with stochastic supplier reliability
and stochastic demand; Working Paper, Warrington College of Business Administration; University of
Florida.
[7] Chang C. (2006), An acquisition policy for a single item multi-supplier system with real-world
constraints; Applied Mathematical Modeling 30; 1–9.
[8] Dahel NE. (2003), Vendor selection and order quantity allocation in volume discount environments;
Supply Chain Management 8; 335-342.

[9] Delgado M., Verdegay J.L., Vila M.A. (1989), A general model for fuzzy linear programming; Fuzzy
Sets and Systems 29; 21–29.
[10] Dornier P.P., Ernst R., Fender M., Kouvelis P. (1998), Global Operations and Logistics: Text and
Cases; Wiley, New York, New York.
[11] Haimes YY., Wismer DA., Lasdon DS. (1971), On bicriterion formulation of the integrated systems
identification and system optimization; IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics SMC-1.
[12] Hassnzadeh Amin S., Razmi J. (2009), An integrated fuzzy model for supplier management: A case
study of ISP selection and evalution; Expert Systems with Applications 36; 8639-8648.
[13] Hassini E., Haouari M., Aissaoui N. (2007), Supplier selection and order lot sizing modeling: A
review; Computers & Operations Research 34; 3516 – 3540.
[14] Figueira J., Greco S., Ehrgott M., (2005), Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis: State of the Art
Surveys; Springer Verlag, Boston, Dordrecht, London; 723-760..
[15] Karimi B., Fatemi Ghomi S.M.T., Wilson JM. (2003), The capacitated lot sizing problem: a review of
models and algorithms; The International Journal of Management Science, Omega 31; 365–378.
[16] Karlin S. (1958), One stage inventory models with uncertainty. In: Arrow KJ, Karlin S, Scarf H,
editors, Studies in the mathematical theory of inventory and production, Stanford: CA, Stanford
University Press.
[17] Lai YJ., Hwang CL. (1992), A new approach to some possibilistic linear programming problems;
Fuzzy Sets and Systems 49; 121–133.
[18] Lai YJ., Hwang CL. (1994), Fuzzy Multiple Objective Decision Making, Methods and Applications;
Springer, Berlin.
[19] Liang TF. (2006), Distribution planning decision using interactive fuzzy multi-objective linear
programming; Fuzzy Sets and Systems 157; 1303-1316.
[20] Mohammad Ebrahim R., Razmi J. (2009), Scatter Search Algorithm for Supplier Selection and Order
Lot-sizing under Multiple Price Discount environment; Advances in Engineering Softwares 40;766-
776.
[21] Parlar M., Wang D. (1993), Diversification under randomness in inventory models; European Journal
of Operational Research 66(1); 52–64.
[22] Ravindran A., Wadhwa V. (2007), Vendor selection in outsourcing; Computers & Operations
Research 34; 3725–3737.
[23] Razmi J., Jafari Songhori M., Khakbaz MH. (2008), An integrated fuzzy group decision making/ fuzzy
linear programming (FGDMLP) framework for supplier evaluation and order allocation; Int J Adv
Manuf Technol; Doi: 10.1007/s001 70-008-1719-7.
[24] Razmi J., Maghool E. (2010), Multi-item supplier selection and lot-sizing planning under multiple
price discounts using augmented ε-constraint and Tchebycheff method; Int J Adv Manuf Technol 49;
379-392.
[25] Reeves GR., MacLeod KR. (1999), Some experiments in Tchebycheff-based approaches for
interactive multiple objective decision making; Computers and Operations Research 26; 11–21.
[26] Rosenthal EC., Zydiac JL., Chaudhry SS. (1995),.Vendor selection with bundling; Decision Sciences
26; 35–48.
[27] Sarkar A., Mohapatra P.K.J (2009), Determining the optimal size of supply base with the consideration
of risks of supply disruptions; International Journal of Production Economics 119(1); 122-135,
doi:10.1016/j.ijpe.2008.12.019.
[28] Stadtler H. (2006), A general quantity discount and supplier selection mixed integer programming
model; Springer-Verlag ,OR Spectrum 29; 723–744.

[29] Steuer RE. (1986), Multiple criteria optimization; Wiley, New York.
[30] Steuer RE., Harris FW. (1980), Intra-set point generation and filtering in decision and criterion space;
Computer and Operation Research 7; 41-53.
[31] Steuer RE., Choo EU. (1983), An interactive weighted tchebycheff procedure for multiple objective
programming; Mathematical programming 26; 326-344.
[32] Tempelmeier H. (2001), A Simple Heuristic for Dynamic Order Sizing and Supplier Selection with
Time-Varying Data; production and operation management 11; 499-515.
[33] Torabi SA., Hassini E. (2008), An interactive possibilistic programming approach for multiple
objective supply chain master planning; Fuzzy Sets and Systems 159; 193–214.
[34] Ustun O., Aktar Demirtas E. (2008), An integrated multi-objective decision making process for
supplier selection and order allocation; Omega 36; 76–90.
[35] Wang Y., Gerchak Y. (1996), Periodic review production models with variable capacity, random yield,
and uncertain demand; Management science 42; 130–7.
[36] Wang R.C., Liang T.F. (2005), Applying possibilistic linear programming to aggregate production
planning; International Journal of Production Economics 98(3); 328-341,
doi:10.1016/j.ijpe.2004.09.011.
[37] Wu D.D., Zhang Y., Wu D.L., Olson D. (2009), Fuzzy multi-objective programming for supplier
selection and risk modeling: A possibility approach; European Journal of Operational Research
122(2); 628-638.
[38] Xia W., Wu Zh. (2007), Supplier selection with multiple criteria in volume discount environments;
Omega 35; 494-500.
[39] Yang S., Yang J., Abdel-Malek L. (2007), Sourcing with random yields and stochastic demand: A
newsvendor approach; Computers & Operations Research 34; 3682–3690.
[40] Yang S., Yang J., Abdel-Malek L. (2004), Multi-supplier Sourcing with Random Yields: A
Newsvendor Approach; The 13th International Working Seminar on Production Economics;
Igls/Innsbruck, Austria.
[41] Zimmermann H.J. (1978), Fuzzy programming and linear programming with several objective
functions; Fuzzy Sets and Systems 1; 45–55.