Methodology based on MCDM for risk management in EPC projects: A Case Study of LPG Storage Tanks Construction

Document Type: Research Paper

Authors

Industrial Engineering College, Islamic Azad University, South Tehran Branch, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

The most important aim of every project is on time completion, budget consideration and reaching the highest possible quality, based on contract. This paper suggests a methodology for risk management in engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) projects. Risk management enables project teams to perform with minimum deviation from predetermined goals. The proposed methodology identifies and evaluates critical risks of EPC projects using multi criteria decision making (MCDM) techniques. Then, by the means of developed earned value management (EVM) technique and considering Project Risk index (PRI), this work will proceed to estimate the degree of risk effects on project objectives. The optimal control measures (CMs) to address the risks are found through a goal programming model. The methodology was implemented on a case study in oil and gas industry in Iran. Results of this study show the impact of critical risks on objectives of EPC projects.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Adedokun, O.A., D.R. Ogunsemi, I.O. Aje, O.A. Awodele and D.O Dairo.(2011).
Evaluation of qualitative risk analysis techniques in selected large construction
companies in Nigeria, Journal of Facilities Management, Vol.11 No. 2, pp. 123-135.
Adedeji B.badiru, olufemi A.omitaomu.(2011),handbook of industrial engineering
equations, formulas and calculations, CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, 6000 Broken
Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300,Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742.
Alam Tabriz Akbar et al.(2013), A Combined Approach of the Earned Value Management
and the Risk Management for Estimating Final Results of Projects in Fuzzy
Environment
Aliverdi Reza, Moslemi Naeni Leila, Salehipour Amir.(2013).Monitoring project duration
and cost in a construction project by applying statistical quality control charts,
International Journal of Project Management 31, 411–423.
Bon-Gang Hwang et al. (2014). Risk management in small construction projects in
Singapore: Status, barriers and impact, International Journal of Project Management 32,
116–124.
Car, V., J.H.M.Tah.(2001),A fuzzy approach to construction project risk assessment and
analysis: construction project risk management system, Advances in Engineering
Software 32, pp.847-857.
Changsoon Park, Suneung Ahn, Sangwon Lee.(2014).A Bayesian decision model based
on expected utility and uncertainty risk, Applied Mathematics and Computation 242,
643–648.
Charnes,A., Cooper, WW., Ferguson,R.,(1995),Optimal estimation of executive compensation
by linear programming, Management Science, 1, 138-151.

Costa Kyle. et al. (2009). Contract Management for International EPC Projects a Major
Qualifying Project Report, Submitted to the Faculty of the Worcester polytechnic
institute.
Fontela, E.and Gabus, A.(1974),The DEMATEL,Innovative Methods, Research Report
: Structural Analysis of the World Problematique, Battelle Institute, Geneva.
Ghezavati Vahidreza, Shojaie Amir Abbas, Esfandiari Hossein, Alavi Kamelia.(2013),
Identifying, Prioritization and Responding to Quality Risks Using COQ Approach in
Construction Industry, Caspian Journal of Applied Sciences Research, 2(6), pp. 21-32.
Gwo-Hshiung Tzeng. Jih-Jeng Huang.(2011),Multiple attribute decision making Methods
and applications.
HL.chan Joseph. et al.(2010),Developing a fuzzy risk assessment model for guaranteed
maximum price and target cost contracts in construction, Journal of Facilities
Management, Vol. 9 No. 1, pp.34-51.
Jun ying liu, Sui pheng low.(2009).Developing an organizational learning-based model for
risk management in Chinese construction firms A research agenda, Disaster Prevention
and Management, Vol. 18 No.2, pp.170-186.
kris, nilson,R.,(2006).Experienced based recommendation on risk allocation for both
owners and contactors, Pegasus.
Mahamid Ibrahim.(2011).Risk matrix for factors affecting time delay in road construction
projects: owners’ perspective, Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management,
Vol. 18 No.6, pp. 609- 617.
Marcelino Sara - Sadaba et al. (2014). Project risk management methodology for small
firms, International Journal of Project Management 32, 327–340.
Mohebbi Amir Hassan, Bislimi Ngadhnjim.(2012).Project Risk Management methodology
Development for Engineering, Procurement and Construction Projects, a Case Study in
the Oil and Gas Industry, Faculty of Economic Sciences, Communication and IT
Karlstads Universitet, Universitetsgatan, 65188, KARLSTAD SWEDEN.
Moore David A.(2013).Security Risk Assessment Methodology for the petroleum and
petrochemical industries, Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 26,
1685-1689.
Murphy Martina et al.(2011).A methodology for evaluating construction innovation
constraint through project stakeholder competencies and FMEA, Construction
Innovation, Vol. 11 No. 4, pp. 416-440.

Odeyinka Henry, Lowe John, Kaka Ammar.(2012),Regression modeling of risk impacts
on construction cost flow forecast, Journal of Financial Management of Property and
Construction, Vol.17, No.3, pp.203-221.
Ozdas Ahmet, okmen onder.(2004).Risk analysis in fixed-price design–build construction
project, Building and Environment 39, pp 229 – 237.
Peixoto Joana, Tereso Anabela.(2014). Gabriela Fernandes, Rui Almeida. Project Risk
Management Methodology: A Case Study of an Electric Energy Organization, Procedia
Technology 16, 1096 – 1105.
Project management body of knowledge. (2013). (PMBOK®) guide-5
the edition.
Rezaie,K., et al. (2007). Using extended Monte Carlo simulation method for the
improvement of risk management: Consideration of relationships between uncertainties,
Applied Mathematics and Computation 190, 1492–1501.
Rodrigues-da-Silva, Luiz Henrique., Crispim, José António.,(2014). The project risk
management process, a preliminary study, Procedia Technology 16, 943 – 949.
Ruey-Chyn Tsaur.(2011).Decision risk analysis for an interval TOPSIS method, Applied
Mathematics and Computation 218, 4295–4304.
Sapori E., Sciutto M., Sciutto G.(2014). A quantitative approach to risk management in
Critical Infrastructures, Transportation Research Procedia 3, 740 – 749.
Samani Babak A., shahbodaghlu Farzad.(2012) , A Fuzzy Systematic Approach to
Construction Risk Analysis, Journal of Risk Analysis and Crisis Response, Vol. 2, No. 4,
275-284.
Taylan Osman, Bafail Abdallah O., Abdulaal Reda M.S., Kabli Mohammed R..(2014).
Construction projects selection and risk assessment by fuzzy AHP and
fuzzy TOPSIS methodologies, Applied Soft Computing 17, 105–116.
Teymouri Maryam, Ashoori Maryam.(2011).The impact of information technology on risk
management , Procedia Computer Science 3, 1602–1608.
Vandevoorde Stephan, vanhouke Mario.(2006),A comparison of different project duration
forecasting methods using earned value metrics, International Journal of Project
Management 24, 289–302.
Wei guo. (2004). Development of a framework for preliminary risk analysis in
transportation projects ,civil engineering.

Xiafengh du, Amory N.Li.(2008) , Monte Carlo simulation and a value-at-risk of
concessionary project the case study of the Guangshen Freeway in China, Management
Research News, Vol. 31 No. 12, pp. 912- 921.
YaoZhang, Zhi-Ping Fan.(2014). An optimization method for selecting project risk
response strategies, International Journal of Project Management 32, 412–422.
Zadeh, Lotfi, Fuzzy sets.(1965),Information and Control 8, 338–353.
Zhang Yanting, Xing Liyun. (2011).Research on Risk Management of Petroleum
Operations, Energy Procedia 5, 2330–2334.