A game theory approach for determining optimum strategy of claim resolution in construction projects

Document Type: Research Paper

Authors

1 Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering, Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan, Iran

2 Department of Industrial Engineering,Isfahan University of Technology(IUT), Isfahan, Iran

Abstract

Claim is a big challenge for the contractors and the owners in construction projects. Claims are considered to be one of the most disruptive events of a project. A suitable claim resolution strategy can prevent the damages to the project and the involved parties. In this research, a mathematical model using game theory is presented to find the optimum strategy for resolving cost-related claims in Design-Bid-Build (DBB) projects. The model investigates the strategies of the contractor and the owner in a consecutive four-step process including: negotiation, mediation, arbitration and litigation. It helps the involved parties to have deeper comprehension of the problem, have a better evaluation of their situation and analyze possible strategies in facing with such circumstances. Considering different scenarios, the points which both parties can agree rationally are proposed with an analytical solution. Finally, two cases of real-world problems are presented and analyzed using the proposed approach and the optimum strategy is determined for each case. Based on the results, some strategies for the owners and contractors are presented in order to be more successful in the claim resolution process.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abdoli, G. and Khirandish, A., 2010. A game theory model of economic opportunistic bidding and claim with a case study in Iran.

Acharya, N.K., Dai Lee, Y. and Man Im, H., 2006. Conflicting factors in construction projects: Korean perspective. Engineering, construction and architectural management, 13(6), pp.543-566.

Alberstein, M., 2006. Forms of mediation and law: Cultures of dispute resolution. Ohio St. J. on Disp. Resol., 22, p.321.

Bakhary, N.A., Adnan, H. and Ibrahim, A., 2014. A survey of Malaysian consultants on construction claim problems. Built Environment Journal, 11(1), pp.1-14.

Baker, E., Mellors, B., Chalmers, S. and Lavers, A., 2013. FIDIC contracts: law and practice. Informa Law from Routledge.

Cappelletti, M., 1993. Alternative Dispute Resolution Process Within the Framework of the World-Wide Access-to-Justice Movement. Mod. L. Rev., 56, p.282.

Castro, J., Gómez, D. and Tejada, J., 2007. A project game for PERT networks. Operations Research Letters, 35(6), pp.791-798.

 

Chan, E.H., Suen, H.C. and Chan, C.K., 2006. MAUT-based dispute resolution selection model prototype for international construction projects. Journal of construction engineering and management, 132(5), pp.444-451.

Chen, Y.Q., Zhang, Y.B. and Zhang, S.J., 2014. Impacts of different types of owner-contractor conflict on cost performance in construction projects. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 140(6), p.04014017.

Chen, T.C., Lin, Y.C. and Wang, L.C., 2012. The analysis of BOT strategies based on game theory–case study on Taiwan's high speed railway project. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 18(5), pp.662-674.

Cheung, S.O., Yiu, T.W. and Chan, H.W., 2009. Exploring the potential for predicting project dispute resolution satisfaction using logistic regression. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 136(5), pp.508-517.

Cheung, S.O. and Suen, H.C., 2002. A multi-attribute utility model for dispute resolution strategy selection. Construction Management & Economics, 20(7), pp.557-568.

Chou, J.S., 2012. Comparison of multilabel classification models to forecast project dispute resolutions. Expert Systems with Applications, 39(11), pp.10202-10211.

Conbere, J.P., 2001. Theory building for conflict management system design. Conflict Resolution Quarterly, 19(2), pp.215-236.

Eid, M.S., El-Adaway, I.H. and Coatney, K.T., 2015. Evolutionary stable strategy for postdisaster insurance: Game theory approach. Journal of Management in Engineering, 31(6), p.04015005.

Estévez-Fernández, A., 2012. A game theoretical approach to sharing penalties and rewards in projects. European Journal of Operational Research, 216(3), pp.647-657.

FANG, J. and REN, H., 2004. Variation Controlling of Construction Contract Performing [J]. Journal of Chongqing University (Natural Science Edition), 6.

Gebken, R.J. and Gibson, G.E., 2006. Quantification of costs for dispute resolution procedures in the construction industry. Journal of professional issues in engineering education and practice, 132(3), pp.264-271.

Goldberg, S.B., Sander, F.E., Rogers, N.H. and Cole, S.R., 2014. Dispute resolution: Negotiation, mediation and other processes. Wolters Kluwer Law & Business.

Rose, K. H., 2017. A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK® Guide)—sixth Edition. Project management journal.

Hipel, K.W., Kilgour, D.M. and Fang, L., 2010. The graph model for conflict resolution. Wiley encyclopedia of operations research and management science.

Ho, S.P. and Hsu, Y., 2013. Bid compensation theory and strategies for projects with heterogeneous bidders: A game theoretic analysis. Journal of Management in Engineering, 30(5), p.04014022.

Ho, S.P. and Liu, L.Y., 2004. Analytical model for analyzing construction claims and opportunistic bidding. Journal of construction engineering and management, 130(1), pp.94-104.

Hollands, D.E., 2014. Alternative dispute resolution in construction. ADR, Arbitration, and Mediation, p.83.

Jaffar, N., Tharim, A.A. and Shuib, M.N., 2011. Factors of conflict in construction industry: a literature review. Procedia Engineering, 20, pp.193-202.

Kassab, M., Hipel, K. and Hegazy, T., 2006. Conflict resolution in construction disputes using the graph model. Journal of construction engineering and management, 132(10), pp.1043-1052.

Kassab, M., Hegazy, T. and Hipel, K., 2010. Computerized DSS for construction conflict resolution under uncertainty. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 136(12), pp.1249-1257.

Kassab, M., Hipel, K. and Hegazy, T., 2011. Multi-criteria decision analysis for infrastructure privatisation using conflict resolution. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 7(9), pp.661-671.

Khanzadi, M., Eshtehardian, E. and Chalekaee, A., 2016. A game theory approach for optimum strategy of the owner and contractor in delayed projects. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 22(8), pp.1066-1077.

Khanzadi, M., Turskis, Z., Ghodrati Amiri, G. and Chalekaee, A., 2017. A model of discrete zero-sum two-person matrix games with grey numbers to solve dispute resolution problems in construction. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 23(6), pp.824-835.

Liu, J., Gao, R., Cheah, C.Y.J. and Luo, J., 2017. Evolutionary game of investors’ opportunistic behaviour during the operational period in PPP projects. Construction management and economics, 35(3), pp.137-153.

Love, P.E., Davis, P.R., Ellis, J.M. and Cheung, S.O., 2010. A systemic view of dispute causation. International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, 3(4), pp.661-680.

Lu, W., Zhang, L. and Pan, J., 2015. Identification and analyses of hidden transaction costs in project dispute resolutions. International journal of project management, 33(3), pp.711-718.

Lv, J., Ye, G., Liu, W., Shen, L. and Wang, H., 2014. Alternative model for determining the optimal concession period in managing BOT transportation projects. Journal of Management in Engineering, 31(4), p.04014066.

Marzouk, M. and Moamen, M., 2009. A framework for estimating negotiation amounts in construction projects. Construction innovation, 9(2), pp.133-148.

Myerson, R. B. (2013). Game theory. Harvard university press.

Mohammadi, S. and Birgonul, M.T., 2016. Preventing claims in green construction projects through investigating the components of contractual and legal risks. Journal of cleaner production, 139, pp.1078-1084.

Ng, H.S., Peña-Mora, F. and Tamaki, T., 2007. Dynamic conflict management in large-scale design and construction projects. Journal of Management in Engineering, 23(2), pp.52-66.

Shen, W., Tang, W., Yu, W., Duffield, C.F., Hui, F.K.P., Wei, Y. and Fang, J., 2017. Causes of contractors’ claims in international engineering-procurement-construction projects. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 23(6), pp.727-739.

Song, X., Peña-Mora, F., Menassa, C.C. and Arboleda, C.A., 2013. Determining the optimal premium for ADR implementation insurance in construction dispute resolution. Journal of Management in Engineering, 30(4), p.04014012.

Thomas, G.C., 1991. ARBITRATION AND THE SMALL PROJECT OWNER: SOME THOUGHTS AND SUGGESTIONS. International Journal of Conflict Management, 2(4), pp.297-308.

Lu, W. and Nie, J., 2008, October. Study of the dynamic game in change pricing between owner and contractor. In 2008 4th International Conference on Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing (pp. 1-6). IEEE.

Wenxue, L. and Jianming, N., 2008. Study of the Dynamic Game in Change Pricing between Owner and Contractor [J]. In 4th International Conference on Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing (No. 10, p. 2008).

Wu, G., Zhao, X. and Zuo, J., 2017. Effects of inter-organizational conflicts on construction project added value in China. International Journal of Conflict Management, 28(5), pp.695-723.

Zaneldin, E.K., 2006. Construction claims in United Arab Emirates: Types, causes, and frequency. International Journal of Project Management, 24(5), pp.453-459.