Implementation Procedures for the Risk in Early Design (RED) Method

Document Type: Research Paper

Authors

1 Department of Interdisciplinary Engineering, Missouri University of Science and Technology, Rolla, MO 65409

2 Department of Mechanical, Industrial, and Manufacturing Engineering Oregon State University

Abstract

Risk assessments performed at the conceptual design phase of a product may offer the greatest opportunity to increase product safety and reliability at the least cost. This is an especially difficult proposition, however, as often the product has not assumed a physical form at this early design stage. This paper introduces the Risk in Early Design (RED) method, a method for performing risk assessments based on functions, rather than physical components, to address this challenge. In particular, this paper focuses on the function based mathematical mappings of the RED method for a preliminary risk assessment based on catalogued historical failure information. An example is presented on how the RED preliminary risk assessment method is used in the design process on a spacecraft thermal control subsystem. Also, heuristics for applying the particular types of risk assessments are discussed. The preliminary risk assessment method discussed offers a potentially paradigm-shifting approach to identifying potential areas of concern in a product during the early stages of design when risk mitigation is least expensive.

Keywords

Main Subjects


[1] Bohnenblust H., Schneider T. (1987), Risk appraisal: Can it be improved by formal decision models?;
Uncertainty in Risk Assessment, Risk Management, and Decision Making; edited by V. T. Covello et
al., pp. 71-87; New York Plenum Press.
[2] Brown A.F.( 1994), Development of a Method for Flight Anomaly Characterization; JPL Technical
Report, JPLD-11382, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA.

[3] Department of Defense, Procedures for performing failure mode, effects and criticality analysis; MILSTD-
1629A.
[4] Frank M.V. (1999), Reentry safety: probability of fuel release in Safety and Reliability; Proceedings of
ESREL ’99, eds G.I. Schueller and P. Kafka, Balkema, Rotterdam.
[5] Grantham Lough K., Stone R., Tumer I. (2005), Function Based Risk Assessment: Mapping Function
to Likelihood; Proceedings of ASME International Design Engineering Technical Conference;
September 24-28, Long Beach, CA.
[6] Grantham Lough K.A. (2005), Risk in Early Design; A Dissertation; University of Missouri-Rolla,
August.
[7] Grantham Lough K., Stone R., Tumer I. (2006), The Risk in Early Design (RED) Method: Likelihood
and Consequence Calculations; Proceedings of ASME International Design Engineering Technical
Conference; Submitted.
[8] Henley E., Kumamoto H. (1992), Probabilistic Risk Assessment; IEEE Press; New York.
[9] Hirtz J., Stone R., McAdams D., Szykman S., Wood K. (2002), A Functional Basis for Engineering
Design: Reconciling and Evolving Previous Efforts; Research in Engineering Design 13(2); 65-82.
[10] Holloway N.J. (1987), A method for pilot risk studies; In Implications of Probabilistic Risk
Assessment; edited by Cullingford M.C., Shah S.M., and Gittus J.H., 125-140., New Yourk; Elsevier
Applied Science.
[11] Kurfman M., Rajan J., Stone R., Wood K., Stock M. (2003), Experimental Studies Assessing the
Repeatability of a Functional Modeling Derivation Method; Journal of Mechanical Design 125(4);
682-693.
[12] Lawley H.G. (1974), Operability studies and hazard analysis; Chemical Engineering Progress 70(4);
45-56.
[13] Mark G. (2002), Extreme Collaboration; Communications of the ACM 45(6); 89-93.
[14] Meshkat Cornford S., Moran T. (2003), Risk Based Decision Tool for Space Exploration Missions;
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics space Conference and Exhibition, AIAA; 2003-
6377.
[15] Miles L. (1972), Techniques of Value Analysis Engineering; McGraw-Hill.
[16] Office of the Under Secretary of Defense (1999), DSMC Risk Management Guide for DoD
Acquisition; 2nd Edition, Defense Systems Management College Press, Fort Belvoir, Virginia.
[17] Otto K., Wood K. (2001), Product Design: Techniques in Reverse Engineering; Systematic Design,
and New Product Development, New York, Prentice-Hall.
[18] Pahl G., Beitz W. (1984), Engineering Design: A Systematic Approach; Design Council, London.
[19] Quinn J.D. (1994), Flight P/FRs and the Design Review Process; JPL Technical Report, JPL D-11381,
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasedena, California.
[20] Stone R., Tumer I., Van Wie M., The Function Failure Design Method; Journal of Mechanical Design;
in press.

[21] Tumer I., Stone R., Bell D. (2003), Requirements for a Failure Mode Taxonomy for use in Conceptual
Design; Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering Design, ICED; Stockholm, paper
1612.
[22] Tumer I., Stone R. (2001), Mapping Function to Failure Mode During Component Development;
Research in Engineering Design 14(1); 25-33.
[23] Uder S., Stone R., Tumer I. (2004), Function Based Risk Assessment and Failure Prediction for
Unmanned Space Missions; ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress IMECE; 60846.
[24] Van Wie M., Bohm M., Barrientos F., Tumer I., Stone R. (2005-1), Learning from Failures: Archiving
and Designing with Failure and Risk; Proceedings of the 6th InternationalConference on Computer-
Aided Industrial Design and Conceptual Design; Delft, The Netherlands.
[25] Van Wie M., Grantham Lough K., Stone R., Barrientos F., Tumer I. (2005-2), An Analysis of Risk and
Function Information in Early Stage Design; Proceedings of ASME International Design Engineering
Technical Conference; September 24-28, Long Beach, CA.
[26] Vesely W.E., Goldberg F.F., Roberts N.H., Haasi D.F. (1981), The Fault Tree Handbook; US Nuclear
Regulatory Commission, NUREG 0492.
[27] Warren J.A. (2005), Personal Communication; April 14, The Boeing Company, St. Louis, MO.